Because Thought Changes the World…Albeit Slowly and from Within

Sep 29, 2026

Last week, alongside other recently promoted professors, I was invited to give a professorial lecture. I took advantage of the occasion to reflect on why I do what I do. I enjoyed the exercise, so I hope you do as well.  You can find the link to the recorded version here:

In my first week at ACU, a video interviewer for a marketing push, asked me: “why did you become a theologian?” I didn’t really think of myself in those terms yet, but you’re on camera, so after a pause, I responded: “Because thought changes the world, albeit slowly and from within.” That understanding of what I am doing remains true now, as I welcome this opportunity to share what being, or becoming, a professor of theology means for me. And I thank Julie Cogin for the opportunity to do so. My work spans a few areas:

  1. Music: I compose and make sense of life and faith through music; that is to say: music as theology, rather than in it.
  2. Research into the role of musicking in human life, which touches on epistemology, aesthetics, and theological method;
  3. Ministry: or rather theological formation and education for ministry.
  4. Catholic Systematic theology of leadership with a few key projects on the go.

Today’s thoughts apply to each of these four spaces, framed in two moments:
“Why?”, and “How, or What for” – Where could we go with this?

 

I. Why theology? Part of this is why here, as I think it goes to the heart of Catholic Education

“We had the experience, but we missed the meaning” TS Elliot

Reflecting on our human experiences, and our faith experiences, understanding them, gaining insight into their significance, their implications before and as we decide how to act, is essential to the quality of our lives, both personal and institutional. In an era in which the very nature of what is human is being challenged, this is foundational. This is not, in my work, a mere exhortation to mindfulness and honest intentionality – good as these are – but a sine qua non of intellectual insight, for which I draw on the thought of John Henry Newman, the critical realism of Bernard Lonergan, Speelman, Pierce, and others. ACU includes truth in its mission statement I am a Catholic theologian. I believe we can access truth. But no one, except the divine, has 20-20 vision. Who we are, where we come from, and our epistemological allegiances colour, condition, enable or blind our access to truth, in the measure that we can access it. The only “access point to “objectivity”, to what is correct, or “truthful”, however we want to call it that, is that of “shared authentic subjectivities”. We have no other. Even knowledge of God comes through human words. So, I embed an epistemological critical reflective praxis in all of my teaching, research, consultancy, and governance training work. The fruits are exciting.

One final reason for the “why” space of theology is about what it offers culture in this polarised “change of era” in which we live. In the words of one of the giants on whose shoulders I stand, (which incidentally describe quite well the push and pull within which ACU sits in Australia):

There is bound to be formed a solid right that is determined to live in a world that no longer exists. There is bound to be formed a scattered left, captivated by now this, now that new development, exploring now this and now that new possibility. But what will count is a perhaps not numerous centre, big enough to be at home in both the old and the new, painstaking enough to work out one by one the transitions to be made, strong enough to refuse half measures and insist on complete solutions even though it has to wait.

Lonergan, Dimensions of Meaning

Thought changes the world…as long as it is strong, courageous, and patient.

II. How Theology, and What For?

In my case, there are three points:

  1. Through music;
  2. Dialogically (and therefore collaboratively);  
  3. With the intent of system change.

1. Musicking: “Let me write a nation’s songs, and I don’t care who writes her laws.” (18th century John Fletcher) We think about the arts as extras, as non-essential, if valuable, aspects of human life. But the opposite is closer to the truth: we are symbolic beings before and as we are rational. Much of our language is distilled from metaphors, faded into the fabric of everyday discourse (Susanne K. Langer). In fact, the lion’s share of the Catholic Intellectual Tradition, of which we, as all universities, are a development, is written, not primarily in words, but in architecture, literature, art works, and music. Humanity’s future will be narrow, thin, and lacking in vision if the creativity intrinsic to human meaning-making is not a central part of things.

Contemplating the Light ©Helen Bachmann

And if we cannot engage people’s symbolic understandings of who they are, and who they want to be, our educational endeavours will be superficial, at best.

  1. Dialogically/with others: This is big, but also concrete. The beauty of Catholic theology, in my view, is that it places us in dialogue with the world, to receive and give. Every question, challenge, and insight from beyond these walls are primary sources—our self-revealing God shows up through others. Questions matter as much as answers. We engage with multiplicity of voices, walking alongside our world to seek ways forward together. Pope Francis asked theology to be open, contextual, inter and intradisciplinary, and networked. That demands collaboration. There is no theology without philosophy; no ethics without health; no learning without pedagogy. We are a university—one whole of collaborative expertise.”

Three projects within which I work demand and reflect this kind of dialogical work:

1. The Xavier Centre for Theological Formation: “Created with colleagues, the Centre serves organisations in health, social services, education, and ministry through ongoing theological formation. Rather than individual academics stretching beyond workhours alone, we built a what I call a “portal”—a space bridging faculty expertise with the world’s needs.

Our vision sees Catholic organisational cultures as deeply life-giving places where we co-construct solid theological responses.”

“The Xavier Centre envisions Catholic organisational cultures as deeply life-giving places in Australia, vibrantly engaged with Catholic tradition, and upholding the dignity of all people in and through the provision of their services….”

2. Holy Spirit Seminary, QLD: I lead the long-term and important collaborative work with the Seminary of the five dioceses of Queensland (and beyond) in the formation of their future leaders. I think its proven record reenforces the trust CTC is now placing in ACU in Victoria and Tasmania, moving forward. Most of all, they are exceptional and trusted colleagues and partners in the theological quest.

3. CROs/CROP: Together with a team of FEA researchers, we’re creating a framework to better understand and verify Creative Research Outputs as rigorous, original contributions to knowledge. You will remember the term “Non-traditional research outputs”, but given my words earlier, this both is incorrect and misses the point. Art is —legitimate research rooted in and continuing the intellectual heritage I mentioned above. We trust CROs will become a well-known term and area of work for ACU, into the future. It might also help more traditional forms of academic research open itself to more creative perspectives. Watch this space!”

  1. With the intent of System Change:

As I reflected on the journey that led me here, I perceived a common denominator: leadership. Formation for leadership, for governance, for systemwide growth and change. To end, I will share a few of these, through words and music:

 

  • Inclusive Governance in a Synodal Church is a research project coming out the Vatican’s Synod on Synodality (in which some of our own have been more involved than I). It seeks to explore and advance how governance of the organisations once led by religious – such as the teaching colleges that gave birth to ACU – might be overseen into the future. And the training necessary, such as the Governance Ministry Leadership Program, and work in the Aggiornamento space created and offered by The Xavier Centre.
  • With the Dicastery for Culture and Education, an ongoing series of worldwide theology Congresses entitled The Future of Theology: Imagination and Legacy. Its inaugural iteration in 2024, gathered over 500 theologians in Rome to hear from diverse voices from around the world.
  • A Theologies of Priesthood Research project, born out of work with the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference on the National Ratio (the universal policy document on formation of Catholic priests). It seeks to rethink, reimagine, and help reshape, how we understand our ordained leaders, presbyters, bishops and indeed, or foundationally, how we think about the baptismal priesthood of all. There are real gaps in knowledge here.
  • Finally: Women in Leadership/ Women’s Leadership for Mission: again built with other colleagues, a Grad Cert created by women and for women, to equip women to take the reins and lead in the spaces into which they are called. I suggest this is, perhaps, the single most urgent issue facing Catholic theology, worldwide. So we need to be in this space.

To end at the beginning: system change is as much symbolic as it is systemic, and in theological terms, this means changing the way we see, or imagine, not only the world and the Church, but also God. This song snippet seeks to express the thought of theologian Elziabeth Johnson (many will remember her book inviting us to address God as “She who is”) and the thirst of many others for a way to pray to a God in whose image all of us, women and men, are made.  

In a co-designed event at St Stephen’s Cathedral last year, an all boys school chose to perform this song, introducing it with these words:

God by Any Other Name: This piece is a response to the exclusively male-gendered language often used for God. It gently reminds us that while Jesus, in his earthly life, was a man, the concept of God as a Creator, and the essence of the Spirit, transcend gender.

Killian Menzies, Marist Chamber Choir

You cannot copy content of this page